What I Weigh Today

23 Jul, 2009

148

Posted by: joymanning In: Uncategorized

I have two announcements I’d like to make.

1) I quit the birth control pill. Whether or not if was affecting my weight, it was absolutely affecting my energy and my mood. I had headaches (which I never get), and my sleeping got even worse. Bye bye, pill. I thought we could make it work, our reunion had its ups and downs, but this time we’re done for good.

2) I will no longer be counting calories. I decided it’s stupid, at least for me. And not something that it makes sense to keep up for life. After writing my post yesterday, discovering this instantly addicting new blog, and reading another 100 pages of The Body Myth, I have decided it is urgently important for me to focus on accepting the body I have now.

One thing that really struck me was this post by Kate Harding, a body image activist and fat acceptance blogger/author. In the post, she writes about the crazy things that people believe about being thin, the things they tell themselves they can’t try until the thin self emerges with a big superhero S on her chest and starts doing all the things you’ve always dreamed of.

She also mentions something she refers to as her cognitive dissonance phase, when she simultaneously believed that she must accept her body the way it was while being equally convinced that it would be impossible until she lost weight.

I thought, holy crap, that is exactly where I am right now. I’m not hopeless. I’m just in the cognitive dissonance phase! That is exactly it. But if I’m to get through it, get to the other side where I can be comfortable in my own skin, I need to keep my eye on the prize and let myself be conflicted without getting confused.

As I declared at the outset of this blog, if I eat when I’m hungry, stop when I’m full, and continue to exercise, whatever I weigh is what I weigh. If my weight fluctuates between 145 and 150 or more, so be it.

8 Responses to "148"

1 | Irina @ PastryPal

July 23rd, 2009 at 4:13 pm

Avatar

I find YOUR blog quite addicting. As a former pastry professional, I can really appreciate your struggle to maintain weight when your job involves HAVING to eat. When faced with something delicious, I just can’t say no. I think you’ve struck a pretty good balance by say, eating light on occasions when your not working. You’re bound to fluctuate by a couple of pounds here and there.

2 | Jen on the Edge

July 23rd, 2009 at 5:00 pm

Avatar

Good for you!!!! I’m glad you’re going to give yourself a bit of a break and just focus on being healthy.

3 | Emily Joyce

July 23rd, 2009 at 5:48 pm

Avatar

great decision…I’m kind of at the same juncture…do you read my mind?

4 | yoko

July 23rd, 2009 at 7:31 pm

Avatar

That’s an awesome post by Kate Harding. There’s so much that makes sense. Love this ending: “The Fantasy of Being Thin is a really convenient excuse for not asking yourself those questions sincerely — and that’s exactly why it’s dangerous. It keeps you from being not only who you are, but who you actually could be, if you worked with what you’ve got.”

5 | Emily Joyce

July 24th, 2009 at 8:20 am

Avatar

dilemma: three months of walking every morning, eating sensibly, enjoying good food and wine=stable weight. Two weeks of keeping a food diary, walking daily, eating sensibly, enjoying good food and (less) wine=5 pound weight loss. I think I’ll keep the diary! Mine is not a “fantasy” weight goal or a rigid, unhappy quest; my cholesterol is high, and I’m trying to avoid medication…

6 | joymanning

July 24th, 2009 at 8:50 am

Avatar

Emily, far be it from me to tell anyone what to do, but if you had a stable weight for three months eating sensibly and living your life while not obsessing, doesn’t that maybe tell you something? You may weigh a few pounds less now, but it’s because the food journaling itself is probably causing you to (consciously or unconsciously) restrict your eating. What if you taper off the food journaling and find yourself up 8 pounds by this time next year?

I hear you about cholesterol; mine is high too. But cholesterol is a complicated issue that isn’t totally understood. Are your ratios of HDL and LDL favorable? How are your triglycerides? It may be genetic and having nothing to do with your diet.

I’m starting to think we should trust our bodies–not our brainwashed minds–when it comes to what we should weigh.

7 | lisa d

July 24th, 2009 at 7:34 pm

Avatar

you said a mouthful,no pun intended,about being brainwashed by the media about the perfect body,weight,style,hairdo,etc etc etc…listen to your little voice it will never steer you wrong if you really listen that is!

8 | Caitlin

July 25th, 2009 at 5:58 pm

Avatar

I’m not hopeless. I’m just in the cognitive dissonance phase!

Heh. Exactly! Mine lasted at least 6 months, and that was after all the time it took me to accept that maybe these fat acceptance people were on to something. It takes time to start to undo all the stuff society’s brainwashed into you.

I remember one day, months and months and months after I’d started reading Shapely Prose ever day (which is the single best thing I’ve ever done for my physical and mental health) I had the thought “What if I never get any thinner than I am now?” And I didn’t freak out, and I didn’t push it away. I mean, I wasn’t like “Yeah! That’d be great!”, but I just let it sit there in my brainspace for a while, and that’s when I knew the cognitive dissonance phase was at the beginning of the end. :D

Mine is not a “fantasy” weight goal or a rigid, unhappy quest; my cholesterol is high, and I’m trying to avoid medication…

Okay, but cholesterol is affected by your dietary intake and the amount of exercise you get, right? What exactly does weightloss have to do with anything? Why tack an impossible fantasy (sustainable weightloss) onto a real and achieveable goal (a healthier way of life)? It’s just going to lead to feeling bad about your weight-based “failures” instead of celebrating your successes in taking steps toward better health.

Comment Form


  • Felicia D'Ambrosio: Say it, sister. You DON'T need to be a rail to be happy and healthy. Women's magazines reinforce every negative thing we think about ourselves, and
  • JeanineBean: Hooray! I've been waiting for this post! Good for you. Let's talk about something ELSE! (-:
  • pauline: I too have struggled with weight but for the first time in a lot of years I am down to 152lbs I think I would be happy at 145 then I could have a litt

About

I'm a 32 year old woman who has struggled with weight and body image issues since preschool. Oh, and I'm also a restaurant reviewer, cookbook author, and all-around food writer--a career path that makes maintaining a healthy weight more of a challenge than it has ever been.